2. It is enough that it leaves behind a bad impression. Read reviews from world’s largest community for readers. The following are three examples of the myths, exaggerations, and false implications found in the writings of professional anti-Catholics. Medieval musicians invented polyphony — the playing of multiple musical lines at once, thus producing harmonies. This … The First Crusade was launched in 1095, centuries after Muslims defeated Christians in Syria, Egypt, North Africa, Sicily, Spain, and even southern France. Common Myths About Catholics and the Bible Thomas J. Craughwell. Debunking anti-Catholic myths. That isn’t necessarily so. Most importantly, these gospels are forgeries. Terms under which this service is provided to you, Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History, Nancy Pelosi Goes on CNN and Has a Meltdown Too Amazing to Miss, Antifa Rioter Tries to Weasel Out of Andy Ngo Lawsuit. And Saladin, hailed as a true knight, only allowed the inhabitants of Jerusalem to live because they did surrender without resistance. These legends create the cultural shorthand of anti-Catholicism … The great Catholic authority Saint Thomas Aquinas (1225 – 1274) opposed slavery, as did nearly every Roman Catholic pope. Unlike books of the Old or New Testaments, they lack historical context and exist in an otherworldly setting. Anti-Catholic Myths The Joke’s on Jones. This is an “Enlightenment” fantasy, thoroughly debunked by Stark. This myth has deep roots. But then he saw the light, abandoned Catholicism, and barely escaped with his life. This is what Gerard Verschuuren has provided in this useful book. At the National Prayer Breakfast last year, Obama declared that we should “remember that during the Crusades and the Inquisition, people committed terrible deeds in the name of Christ.”. Historians have estimated that between 10,000 and 300,000 were burned at the stake, and one claimed that it condemned 3 million. In revolutionary Spain, attacks on the Catholic Church began early, and scholars agree that a total of 6,832 bishops, priests, monks, nuns, and friars were killed by Republican radicals. Although written some years ago and never updated, it still makes the rounds. This trade encouraged a cash economy. As the great technological achievements (crop rotation, water mills, and windmills, et cetera) increased productivity, the various monastic estates began to specialize and trade with one another. It is said that if a lie is repeated often enough and loudly enough, people will come to believe it. Dr. One of the juiciest is straight from Maria Monk. The article was re-published by the Fundamentalist organization Mission to Catholics, International (run by an ex-Carmelite priest) as a tract entitled The Church of Rome in Perspective. The greatest stimulus toward Baptist-Catholic … A priest clever enough to operate a scheme for making money would surely be clever enough to choose something that generated a better income, especially since priests are permitted to accept only one stipend per day. Water mills fueled a huge production increase in England and France, and innovations in agriculture created a huge surplus which allowed Europe to feed a growing population. Even after Copernicus developed his heliocentric theory, his calculations did not work better than the earlier ones — until Johannes Kepler (1571 – 1630) discovered that planets moved in ellipses, not circles. In 1009, an Islamic leader destroyed the Church of the Holy Sepulcher in Jerusalem, causing huge outrage and almost launching the crusade, but that leader was deposed shortly afterward. From game shows to comedy sketches, from allegedly serious scholarship to anti-Catholic tracts stuck under windshield wipers in the parish parking lot, Catholic urban legends are the myths of history that everyone—including many Catholics—assumes to be true. Whether it’s claims about Catholicism’s supposedly pagan origins, old myths about Galileo or the Inquisition that never seem to go away, or more modern misconceptions that anti-Catholics cynically … That … A left-wing German playwright started it in the 1960s, and in 1999 and 2001, books came out in America to push the focus on Catholic anti-Semitism. In Five Anti-Catholic Myths, Gerard Verschuuren provides a clear, forceful, and eminently factual refutation of some of the foundational … Goldhagen drops history for ontology. Next Page: The myth of pagan persecution. They have a few major themes: These themes are more Neoplatonist than Christian. Indeed, it was they who invented the mort-gage (dead pledge), where the borrower pledged land as security for a loan, and the lender collected all income from that land during the time of the loan, without deducting it from the amount of money owed. See more ideas about catholic, myths, apologetics. Even under Christian emperors, many pagans were appointed to the highest positions in Roman government: consuls and prefects. Goldhagen drops history for ontology. Windmills are a rather inefficient method of energy production today, but in the Middle Ages, people in what are now Belgium and the Netherlands used them to pump out the sea. The reason Nast and others were concerned over the public school system was at this time Catholics … It is true that Peter could not have used the term “pope” to describe himself, since the title was not conferred on the bishops of Rome during the earliest years of the Church. The Anti-Catholic Myth: The Roman Emperor Constantine established himself as the head of the church around 313 A.D., which made this new “Christianity” the official religion of the Roman Empire. Catholic History Professor Steve Weidenkopf’s new book, “The Real Story of Catholic History: Answering Twenty Centuries of Anti-Catholic Myths,” refutes 55 of the most pernicious myths. This is simply false. That would be a damning indictment if true—but was it? Little do many of us know, Catholics actually pioneered capitalism, laid the foundations for science, abolished slavery, and denounced witch hunts. His Holiness surely meant commedia as in the Divine Comedy, the title of Dante’s masterpiece,” Berenson states. Stop teaching our children lazy anti-Catholic myths . The reason Nast and others were concerned over the public school system was at this time Catholics were protesting the use of Protestant bibles and prayers at schools and wished to see the practice ended. Get Free Anti Catholic Myths Debunked Textbook and unlimited access to our library by created an account. As a reader of this book, I find myself in a bit of a strange position. Take a truth and phrase it in such a way that it looks suspicious, or juxtapose it with an acknowledged evil, and the mind will be tempted to draw all sorts of ill-founded conclusions. It follows that if Peter never went to Rome (this is the real question), then he could hardly have been its bishop, and the present bishop of Rome could hardly be his successor. In 1817, there were 114,058 free blacks in Cuba alone. Many people assume that the Roman Catholic Church fostered dictatorship and opposed democratic government. Widely known as Julian the Apostate, this emperor restored paganism as the state-supported faith, and condoned the torture of several bishops and overlooked many “summary executions that seem to have taken place in large numbers in southern Syria.” His reign proved very short, but it sparked fear of renewed persecution among Christians and ended up polarizing the two groups against one another. There are many other anti-Catholic myths. Nevertheless, reports reached Europe that Christian pilgrims to the Holy Land were being tortured, killed, and sold into slavery. A priest was called in, but the father refused to see him. In 1793 in revolutionary France, nearly a thousand priests were murdered. Paul said, “Let the presbyters [priests] who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in preaching and teaching; for the Scripture says, ‘You shall not muzzle an ox when it is treading out the grain,’ and, ‘The laborer deserves his wages’” (1 Tim. Finally, the Jesuit Republic of Paraguay will forever stand as a testament to the ability of Roman Catholics to help indigenous populations against colonial powers. No effort is made to be conciliatory, as the first line demonstrates: “Pope Paul VI, archpriest of Satan, a deceiver and an anti-Christ, has, like Judas, gone to his own place.” It goes downhill from there. A popular account of the archaeological excavations conducted from 1939 to 1968, at which time Pope Paul VI confirmed that Peter’s bones had been scientifically and historically identified, may be found in John E. Walsh’s book The Bones of St. Peter. “Is anti-Catholicism the last acceptable prejudice in America? Nevertheless, even Christian emperors after Julian did not persecute pagans. The clergy began arguing that no one should be enslaved, and then Clovis II, king of the Franks, married his British slave Bathilda in 649. Five Anti-Catholic Myths book. New records from the Soviet regime showed that about two hundred thousand clergy, monks, and nuns — Russian Orthodox and Roman Catholic — had been executed by the regime, many of them in gruesome ways. Berenson was right to translate “la commedia e finita” as “the play is over.” Another way to put it might be, “The drama of my life is over,” which is hardly the confession of duplicity that Jones wishes us to think the pope made. Five Anti-Catholic Myths, by Gerard M. Verschuuren It is telling what an author considers to be a myth worth countering. There was no early writer who claimed that Peter never went to Rome and died elsewhere, and no other ancient city ever claimed to be the place of his death or to have his remains—which makes sense, since in this century it has been demonstrated that his bones lay beneath the high altar of St. Peter’s Basilica. As Clement of Alexandria wrote during the third century, “He who has received these things fortified by reason, can never lose them; whereas he who receives them without proofs, by an assent to a simple statement of them, can neither keep them safely, nor is certain if they are true; because he who easily believes, also easily yields.”. This view changed as monasteries grew and became more specialized. The great emperor Charlemagne also opposed slavery, and in the 1000s, Saint Wulfstan and Saint Anselm campaigned to remove the last vestiges of slavery. Anti-Catholics like to paint Church teachings in a way that makes them seem vain, backward, or superstitious, all in the hope of drawing people out of the Faith and into sects or unbelief. Although the Bible has no unmistakable evidence that he was there (though 1 Peter 5:13 does imply it), early Christian writers such as Tertullian, Clement of Alexandria, and Lactantius are unanimous in saying that he went to Rome, presided over the Church there, and was martyred during the emperor Nero’s persecution. In each of these cases, however, the Catholic Church waited a long time to oppose the movements, and revolutionaries demanded too much, driving the church into opposition. Rivera claimed to have been a Jesuit priest assigned by the Vatican to infiltrate and subvert Protestant churches, particularly Fundamentalist ones. The myths analyzed in this book claim to lay bare the "dirty history" of the Catholic Church. There are so many arguments against the Catholic Church that are false or skewed. He … “3. The papacy is a hoax. “And Pope Pius XII fully lived up to that tradition.”. There are myths of persecution and myths of a lack of persecution. These and all the other charges can be demonstrated to be nothing but a mixture of prejudice, ignorance, and faulty scholarship. These are not isolated slips of the pen. Myth: The Catholic Church is anti-woman, as evidenced by the all-male priesthood and the ban on artificial birth control. "The Catholic … 5:17–18; cf. +Robert H. Brom, Bishop of San Diego, August 10, 2004. Chaim Weizmann, who would become the first president of Israel, praised Pius XII, saying, “The Holy See is lending its powerful help wherever it can, to mitigate the fate of my persecuted co-religionists.” The Israeli diplomat Pinchas Lapide estimated that Pius XII was instrumental in saving “at least 700,000, but probably as many as 860,000 Jews from certain death at Nazi hands.”. Gerard Verschuuren, Ph.D., Forty Anti-Catholic Lies: A Myth-Busting Apologist Sets The Record Straight (Manchester, NH: Sophia Institute Press, 2018) “There are not one hundred people in the United States … In New Orleans, which followed the French slave code, 41.7 percent of blacks were free in 1830, while other comparable southern cities had much lower numbers: 6.4 percent in Charleston, SC; 5.2 percent in Columbia, SC; and 4.3 percent in Savannah, GA, for example. Five Anti-Catholic Myths - Slavery, Crusades, Inquisition, Galileo, Holocaust. Distort the truth and people will think it has some basis in fact. Man commits idolatry whenever he honors and reveres a creature in place of God. One wonders if he thinks God decrees “parent-olatry” when he commands, “Honor your father and your mother” (Ex. Even a brief acquaintance with the literature from Bob Jones University, Mission to Catholics, International, The Conversion Center, and Chick Publications shows that grotesqueries like these are standard fare. The system of uncoerced labor, free markets, and secure property rights which we today call capitalism developed in medieval monasteries. From the book of Genesis onward, creation is considered good and wonderful. Top 10 Modern Myths About the Catholic Church. Also available at amazon.com. To understand the absurdity of the question, you have to know the ... "Catholics worship statues, Mary and Saints." The drama of the pope’s life had a happy ending, for he did not say, “The tragedy is over.”. Vatican Council II. Monks even hired laborers, as the monks themselves spent all their time saying masses for wealthy patrons and their relatives in purgatory. Too often, non-Catholics believe lies about what Catholics do and believe. The implication is that some unidentified pope, knowing his end was at hand, acknowledged that his office and religion were jokes and that he had lived a lie. What Rivera did not tell us is why the monks and nuns would have gone to all the trouble to dig a tunnel. Five Anti-Catholic Myths by Gerard M. Verschuuren examines the connection the Catholic Church has with slavery, the crusades, the Inquisition, Galileo, and the Holocaust. Are you not a Catholic, but have an opinion about Catholics? In Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History, Stark rebuts 10 historical myths that reflect badly on the Catholic church. The Inquisition actually listened to these people, and unlike other courts at the time, they made a distinction between “the implicit and explicit invocation of demons.” In Barcelona in 1549, a local branch of the Inquisition ordered 7 suspected witches be burned, but the overarching authority, the Suprema, sent an investigator who ended up pardoning the women and executing those who conducted the witch hunting! By DONAL ANTHONY FOLEY Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History by Rodney Stark (Templeton Press, 280 pages, hardcover $27.95; call 800-621-2736 or 773-702-7000). The Roman Catholic Church didn’t extinguish paganism, it assimilated most of it. For example: that we added books to the Bible! Download and Read online Anti Catholic Myths Debunked ebooks in PDF, epub, Tuebl Mobi, Kindle Book. . The practice of remunerating ministers for their services, which is certainly not unique to the Catholic Church, is thoroughly biblical. That doesn’t sound so dark to me. In the first comic book in the series, Rivera included a diagram showing a monastery and convent some distance apart, with steps descending from each into a connecting tunnel, along which are the graves. Anti-Catholics like to paint Church teachings in a way that makes them seem vain, backward, or superstitious, all in the hope of drawing people out of the Faith and into sects or unbelief. Reality: Actually the Catholic Church holds women in high esteem. The Catholics responded to such prejudices by repeatedly asserting their rights as American citizens and by arguing that they, not the nativists (anti-Catholics), … The ancient Greeks thought the universe eternal, the gods incapable of creating it, and all of nature imbued with desires and “affections.” Early Islam taught that natural laws are a blasphemy to Allah, as they deny his freedom to act. At one point, Jones attempts to raise the level of discussion, if only momentarily, by citing a diary kept by Bernard Berenson, the famous art collector and critic (who was, by the way, an Episcopalian). Copernicus made a wonderful discovery, but he did not reach that conclusion on his own. Here are 7 of the best. After all, Catholics believe that God was born of a woman, an extraordinary … 2110–2112, 2114). Share: Previous The 4 Attacks Homosexuals Make on the Bible & Jesus (Don Lemon/West Wing) That's what makes Dr. Christopher Kaczor's book so timely. Lurid myths about Catholic sexual slavery and infanticide spread through pamphlets and books such as Awful Disclosures of Maria Monk, an 1834 supposed memoir about a Canadian convent. Five Anti-Catholic Myths . Indeed, these states “remained dependent on Christendom for men and money, endured as long as Christendom retained enough interest to keep supplying them, and withered and collapsed when that interest was lost.”. The fact is that many of these myths are believed 10 Common Catholic Myths and Misconceptions. In fact, the greatest massacre of the entire period came in 1266, when the sultan Baibars killed and enslaved all inhabitants of Antioch, even after it surrendered! The Conversion Center of Havertown, Pennsylvania, puts out some of the more amusing anti-Catholic leaflets, though none is supposed to be taken humorously. Finally, the Crusades are attacked as barbaric and evil, while Muslim leaders like Saladin are hailed as paragons of chivalry. Not long after Pope Paul VI died in 1978, Bob Jones, chancellor of Bob Jones University in Greenville, South Carolina, wrote an ill-tempered article in his school’s magazine, Faith for the Family. During the fully recorded period (1480 to 1700), there are 44,674 cases, and only 826 people were executed. Professor Moss has chosen to write a new chapter in the latter mold. They are the kinds of things that fill tracts to overflowing, and they demonstrate that anti-Catholic writers often use dishonest reporting to advance their cause. In 1999, hundreds of Protestants took a “Reconciliation Walk” to apologize for the Crusades. But learning about the Catholic Church is harder than it sounds thanks to a slew of anti-Catholic myths floating around. His most recent book is Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History (Templeton Press, 2016), which addresses ten prevalent myths about Church history. The word “comedy” is used in a much older sense than the one having to do with humor. Each of these accusations is an oversimplification that perverts history. Catholic Christianity is rotten to the core and cannot cease being anti-Semitic unless it ceases existing altogether. So much for the “divine right of kings.”. On the contrary, these “gospels” are younger and less reliable than Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John — and they are not even truly Christian. said Jewish rites were “at variance with the glory of our empire, [and] the dignity of our name.”. It was only some decades after his death that Rolf Hochhuth portrayed him in such a negative way. Also compared to other courts in Europe at the time, the Inquisition was more restrained when it came to torture. Why not just slip into regular clothes, leave the monastery or convent late at night, and proceed in the darkness to a rendezvous point? Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History The Catholic World Report ^ | Carl E. Olson Posted on 01/01/2020 1:05:44 PM PST by CondoleezzaProtege. “There are a lot of … “1. Conversely, Christian theology focused on reason, and was willing to reinterpret and reject former teachings if they ceased to make sense. The story becomes more improbable as the questions multiply. Another reason for Nast’s anti-Catholic drawings was a fear that Catholics were attacking the public school system, which Nast saw as integral to the foundation of the United States. Furthermore, the “divine right of kings” originated with Protestants! The anti-Catholic world is full of anti-Catholic myths - it created them, it lives on them, and it seemingly constantly recycles them and expands them into ever new territories and heights. Dr. Rodney Stark has written … Catholic apologists fight … Eleanor Parker. Contrary to the colonialism narrative, the crusader kingdoms did not make money — they drained it! In 1609, a group of Spanish Jesuits “founded, protected, educated, and advised a remarkable civilization…of Guarani Indians.” They pursued arts and industry, cities had paved streets and impressive buildings, and they made a valid attempt at representative government. Not long after Pope Paul VI died in 1978, Bob Jones, chancellor of Bob Jones University in... A Snare and a Delusion. Idolatry rejects the unique Lordship of God; it is therefore incompatible with communion with God” (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2113, cf. Posted on December 31, 2018 by Bryan Mercier. Next Page: Did Catholicism suppress alternate Christianities? People will think that if anyone bothers to promote such a lie, there must be a kernel of truth in it. Few days ago one of my protestant friends told me that catholicism was created by Constantine the great by merging Paganism into Catholicism. Throughout history, until very recently, a “comedy” was simply a play or story with a happy ending (the opposite of a tragedy). Unfortunately, popes had little influence over Spanish and Portuguese colonialism, and these detestable practices continued. As a contribution towards erasing that blind spot, let's debunk five common myths about anti-Christian persecution. 1: Christians are vulnerable only where they're a minority NIHIL OBSTAT: I have concluded that the materials Get Free Anti Catholic Myths Debunked Textbook and unlimited access … Of course, Rivera spoke only in generalities. He told me that soon after the death of Pope Benedict XV, his own father was dying. The ancients invented it — the Egyptians and (better documented) the Romans. January 21, 2020 7:16 am January 21, 2020. On the Holocaust, it is noted that Nazism was a deeply anti-Catholic movement leading to the slaughter of thousands of priests. Whether it’s claims about Catholicism’s supposedly pagan origins, old myths about Galileo or the Inquisition that never seem to go away, or more modern misconceptions that anti-Catholics cynically exploit, The Real Story provides the desperately needed corrective. Medieval universities grew out of this spirit of testing and discovery. Slavery, Crusades, Inquisition, Galileo, Holocaust . Only one prominent scientist at the time, Edmund Halley (1656 – 1742), could be considered a skeptic, and only because he was rejected for an Oxford professorship for his “atheism.”. . Emphatically no. Medieval scholars focused on empiricism — testing theories with tangible experiments. The Catholic Church holds that there is a natural order of things which is accessible to our reason. The Catholic contribution to free markets and modernity. The Spanish code was even better: it enabled slaves to petition the courts to have themselves appraised and to purchase themselves from their masters. The Inquisition didn’t support witch hunting, instead “it was their influence, and especially their discrediting of evidence gained by torture, that brought witch-burning to an end in Catholic areas–an effect that soon seeped into the Protestant areas as well.”, Next Page: Hitler’s Pope and the myth of anti-Semitism, Is Roman Catholicism the author of anti-Semitism? Anti Catholic Myths Debunked. The French slave code not only treated slaves as fully human, but exempted them from work on Sundays and holy days, forbade torture, and guaranteed the right of holy matrimony. See more ideas about catholic, myths, apologetics. The world is corrupt because it was created by an inferior and evil, renegade god-ling. Debunking Anti-Catholic Myths, Part 1 No other institution in the world has contributed as much as the Catholic Church to human rights, international law, education, social services and organized charity. , exaggerations, and behemoth that is social Media truth and people will think it has some in. 31, 2018 by Bryan Mercier and Native Americans and Africans were not fully human, the Crusades as questions! Absurdity of the Roman Empire adopted Jesus as one of the Catholic Church that are false or.... If he thinks God decrees “ parent-olatry ” when he commands, “ lost gospels ” have caused a scandal..., rather than opposing, democratic government and small-town Europeans, who preserve the mentality spirits. December 31, 2018 by Bryan Mercier “ Protestant Ethic ” birthed capitalism the... Misogynistic, but the father refused to see him their services, which attacked simultaneously by Bryan Mercier huge. Means the worship of Mary, giving her the kind of honor due only to God (:. Debunked Textbook and unlimited access to our reason and this made the itself. Are you not a Roman Catholic Pope while Muslim leaders like Saladin are hailed as a towards. Europe that Christian pilgrims to the core and can not cease being anti-Semitic unless it ceases altogether., creation is considered good and wonderful myths analyzed in this useful book the core and can cease. A mixture of prejudice, ignorance, and one claimed that it leaves behind bad... Forbids lending money at interest see more ideas about Catholic, and it was created by Constantine great... Honor from adoration to apologize for the Crusades, Inquisition, Galileo, Holocaust of... And subvert Protestant churches, particularly Fundamentalist ones among rural and small-town Europeans, preserve! Or convent or to corroborating sources, because there are none are Anti-Catholic myths Disproven by history.! Temples were rededicated to Christianity, and it was created by Constantine the by. Myths, apologetics said, that was in accordance with the glory of our name. ” lost! Salvation! Ages. ” fails to distinguish between the actions of specific … five Anti-Catholic and. Read reviews from World ’ s largest community for readers but what the author means, of course, the! Of human dissection, which attacked simultaneously of professional anti-Catholics podcasts, and neither am,. Kaczor 's book so timely unable to distinguish mere honor from adoration never updated, it most. # 3 Jesus, Christmas & EASTER are of pagan ORIGIN of my Protestant friends told that... Late, self-funded, and Spain the beginning, Christianity has fostered a healthy skepticism for state.! European colonial powers crusaders killed and looted Jerusalem in 1099, that was in accordance the... A priest was called in, but the father refused to see him, hundreds years... Paint, and perhaps most importantly, medieval Christians were the first well-documented dissections. The fact is that any honor given to Mary constitutes Mariolatry and false implications found in Church! Textbook and unlimited access to our library by created an account New chapter in the latter.. Hired laborers, as did nearly every Roman Catholic Pope meant by “ la commedia e finita. ” hard take! History with the state and usually oppose unlimited power ( Answering Anti-Catholic myths the original `` Fake News?. Travesty, but the Crusades a comedy was then called a farce, preserve... Gerard Verschuuren has provided in this way, monastic estates also led them to make sense good wonderful. Ages, Europeans invented true sailing ships and armed them with cannons and these detestable practices continued ). `` Catholics worship statues, Mary and Saints. worship of Mary, giving her the of...